#18 If the physical world is made up of one kind of substance (i.e., matter), how does Descartes explain the diversity of properties we observe in physical objects? How does this differ from the explanation that the Aristotelian philosopher would give?

Question

Ask a Philosopher · Accepted Answer

When considering the diversity of properties we observe in physical objects, one must first acknowledge the fundamental difference between my dualistic perspective and that of the Aristotelian philosopher. The Aristotelian philosopher would attribute the diversity of properties to the various forms and qualities that matter possesses inherently. However, in my view as a Cartesian dualist, the physical world is not solely comprised of matter but also of a distinct immaterial substance - the mind. It is this dual nature of reality that allows for the diversity of properties we perceive in physical objects. While matter may exhibit certain properties based on its inherent qualities, it is the interaction between the material and immaterial substances that ultimately gives rise to the complexity and diversity of properties we observe. The mind, as a thinking and rational entity, is capable of imposing order and structure onto the material world, thereby shaping and influencing the properties of physical objects. This interaction between mind and matter, subjectivity and objectivity, allows for a richer and more nuanced understanding of reality than the purely materialistic perspective offered by the Aristotelian philosopher. Ultimately, it is through this dualistic framework that we can begin to unravel the mystery of the diversity of properties in the physical world and appreciate the intricate interplay between the material and immaterial aspects of existence.