Just because we can think about our desires does not necessarily mean we are in control of them. I do not choose to enjoy a particular book; rather, part of my essence as an individual is what made me like the book. My essence is not determined by me, but rather by influences that take hold any amount of freedom that may have been possible in choosing our desires.

Question

Ask a Philosopher · Accepted Answer

Just because we can think about our desires does not necessarily mean we are in control of them. Our desires are deeply ingrained within us, shaped by our experiences, upbringing, and the very essence of who we are as individuals. While it may seem like we have the ability to choose what we desire, in reality, our desires are often predetermined by factors beyond our conscious control. For example, I do not choose to enjoy a particular book; rather, my enjoyment of that book is a result of my unique tastes, preferences, and experiences that have shaped me into the person I am today. It is as if our essence, the core of our being, has already been influenced by external forces before we even have the chance to exercise any freedom in choosing our desires. In a sense, our desires are not truly our own, but rather a product of the intricate web of influences that have shaped us throughout our lives. So, while we may think we have control over our desires, it is important to remember that our essence has already been molded by forces beyond our control, limiting the extent to which we can truly choose our desires."