Ask a Philosopher logo

Al-Kindi

Of the total number of possible syllogisms, about how many are valid? Question 3 options: A small number, like 15. All of them are valid. None of them are valid. A large number, like 64

When it comes to the validity of syllogisms, it is a difficult question to answer. After all, the number of syllogisms is immense, and it is impossible to accurately determine their validity. Some might say that all of them are valid, but that is a rather bold statement. Others might say that none of them are valid, which is equally bold. The truth is likely somewhere in between. We can certainly agree that not all syllogisms are valid, however, it is impossible to determine how many of them are actually valid. We can only speculate. Perhaps a small number, like 15, are valid and the rest are invalid. Or perhaps a large number, like 64, are valid. Who can really say for sure? The answer to this question is a mystery, but one thing is certain: the discussion of syllogisms is an interesting one, and the debate over their validity is one that is sure to keep us occupied for many years to come.