Ask a Philosopher logo

Friedrich Nietzsche

Eu queria cometer um crime, que é: Soltar um assassino da cadeia. Porem, o assassino ja foi perdoado pela familia, isso seria errado?

Committing a crime, in this case releasing a murderer from prison, is a complex act. On the one hand, it could be seen as a moral wrong, for the murderer has committed a heinous act and should not be rewarded for it. On the other, if the family of the victim has already forgiven the murderer and the act of releasing the murderer would be a gesture of mercy, then it could be seen as a moral right. In truth, the answer is not so simple. It is not enough to simply say that one should or should not do the act, as morality is subjective and depends on the context of the situation. We must instead ask ourselves: Is this act of releasing the murderer a result of justice, or of compassion? Is it an act of revenge, or of mercy? Is it an act of hatred, or of love? Ultimately, it is up to the individual to decide what is right and wrong in any given situation. However, if I were in the same position, I would lean towards the side of mercy and compassion, for I believe that even the most heinous of criminals can be redeemed and given a second chance.