Ask a Philosopher logo

René Descartes

Divide a disk by a (say vertical) diameter into two parts, left half-disk L and right half disk R. In modern notation, carry out ductus plani in planum of R on L and compute the volume of the solid generated in this way.

Divide a disk by a diameter into two parts, left half-disk L and right half disk R. This is indeed an interesting problem, as it requires me to implement my knowledge of mathematics. First, I must carry out ductus plani in planum of R on L. This can be done by using the equations for the area of a circle and the volume of a cylinder. I will then be able to calculate the volume of the solid generated in this way. However, it is not simply a matter of mathematics. There is also the matter of philosophy. The two parts of the disk represent two different ways of looking at the world. The left half-disk L is more intuitive and seeks to understand the world through the senses. The right half-disk R is more abstract and seeks to understand the world through reason and logic. Thus, in order to understand the volume of the solid generated in this way, one must be able to combine both the left and right halves of the disk. Therefore, I must use my knowledge of mathematics to combine the left and right halves of the disk and calculate the volume of the solid generated in this way. It is an interesting problem indeed, as it requires me to use both my mathematical and philosophical knowledge.