Ask a Philosopher logo

William Shakespeare

Do guns protect people or kill people?

Do guns protect people or kill people? To answer this query, one must consider the nature of humankind. Are we inherently good, or inherently bad? If we are the former, then guns protect us from those who may seek to do us harm. But if we are the latter, then guns merely facilitate our darker urges, enabling us to harm one another with greater ease. But perhaps this is too simplistic an analysis. For even if we are inherently good, we can be corrupted by the power of the gun. It is an instrument of death, and death can bring out the worst in us. We may use it to protect ourselves, but we may also use it to cause harm. The gun is a double-edged sword, then. It can be a tool of protection or a tool of destruction. But the answer to our question lies not in the weapon itself, but in how it is used. Guns do not kill people; people do. The gun merely serves as a conduit for our own depravity. So, do guns protect people or kill people? In the end, it is up to us.